Ready for Kindergarten or Ready to Wait? Rethinking Fall Birthdays and Redshirting

If your child has a fall birthday, you’ve likely found yourself facing one of the most emotionally loaded decisions in early childhood:
Should we send them to kindergarten, or should we wait?

This question isn’t just logistical. It’s wrapped in identity, expectations, and fear of “getting it wrong.”

I know this decision personally. My own daughter’s birthday landed right at the cutoff, and after months of observation, professional input, and reflection, I chose to hold her back.

I’m a mom and the CEO of a child development company. I spend my days working alongside pediatric occupational therapists, speech-language pathologists, and other specialists who support children across developmental stages. And still, this was not an easy call.

But it clarified something I wish more families were told:

Kindergarten readiness is not about what a child knows.
It’s about how a child experiences the world.

What Kindergarten Readiness Actually Means

When parents think about kindergarten readiness, they often focus on academics:

• Can my child recognize letters?
• Can they count?
• Can they write their name?

But in real classrooms, success is driven far more by skills like:

• Emotional regulation
• Frustration tolerance
• Ability to transition between activities
• Listening and following multi-step directions
• Navigating peer relationships
• Managing sensory input in busy environments
• Independence with basic tasks

These skills are neurological. They mature with time, not pressure.

Two children can be the same age on paper and dramatically different in how ready their nervous systems are for the demands of school.

Why an Extra Year Can Change Everything

For many children, especially those born close to cutoff dates, an extra year doesn’t delay learning. It strengthens the foundation that learning is built on.

An extra year can offer:

• Increased emotional resilience
• Stronger self-confidence in group settings
• Better regulation during stress
• Improved stamina for full school days
• More positive early school experiences

When children enter kindergarten feeling capable instead of constantly catching up, school becomes a place of curiosity and growth, not overwhelm.

And that difference matters more than early academics ever could.

The “Youngest in the Class” Effect — Now and Later

One of the biggest factors in my own decision was not just kindergarten itself, but what comes after.

Being the youngest child in a grade can ripple forward in ways parents don’t always consider:

• Social maturity gaps become more visible in later elementary school
• Physical differences can feel amplified in middle school
• Puberty can arrive later relative to peers, impacting confidence
• Executive functioning demands increase faster than some children can adapt

None of these outcomes are guaranteed. Many youngest-in-the-class children thrive.

But when a child already needs more support with regulation, confidence, or transitions, stacking “youngest” on top of that can quietly make things harder than they need to be.

For my daughter, I didn’t want her first decade of school to feel like an exercise in pushing uphill.

Let’s Talk About the Stigma of Holding a Child Back

There is real stigma around holding a child back or repeating kindergarten.

Parents worry:

• Will people think something is wrong?
• Will my child feel behind?
• Will this label them?

Here’s the truth we don’t say out loud enough:

Waiting is not the same as failing.

In fact, in many parts of the world, starting later is the norm. In the U.S., we’ve tied age to progress in a way that often ignores development.

Most children do not internalize shame unless adults attach it.

Children internalize confidence when:

• School feels manageable
• They experience success early
• They aren’t constantly compared or corrected
• They feel capable in their bodies and emotions

And importantly, many children never even know they were “held back” unless it’s framed that way.

Holding Back Is Not About Lowering Expectations

This is not about avoiding challenge.

It’s about matching challenge to readiness.

Children grow most when expectations are just slightly ahead of where they are — not when they’re so far ahead that the child spends their energy coping instead of learning.

An extra year can give children the space to grow into expectations rather than struggle under them.

How to Think About the Decision Without Fear

If you’re wrestling with this choice, ask yourself:

• How does my child handle stress and change?
• Do they recover easily from frustration?
• Do they enjoy group learning, or does it drain them?
• Are they confident socially, or still finding their footing?
• Do they seem excited by challenge, or overwhelmed by it?

And remember: choosing to wait is not closing doors.
It’s often opening them wider.

A Final Thought for Parents Standing at This Crossroads

Kindergarten is not a race. Childhood is not something to optimize.

The goal is not early entry.
The goal is a child who feels steady, confident, and ready to learn.

Sometimes the most powerful gift we can give our children is time — time for their nervous systems to mature, time for confidence to take root, and time to enter school feeling like they belong.

If you’re unsure, speaking with a pediatric occupational therapist, speech-language pathologist, or child development specialist can help you understand your child’s readiness more clearly. Not to label. Not to rush. But to support.

You’re not behind.
You’re being thoughtful.
And that matters more than any cutoff date.

‍

Download our Kindergarten Readiness Checklist

‍

Need support, take our developmental screener or schedule an evaluation.